What to do about the Scotland player

Scottish Rugby does a pretty good job of accomplishing this all-powerful juggling, but things are inevitable as it has only two professional teams. A great total of 46 battle day points are ready in any weekend and the result is a terrific set of good rugby players, playing very little high level rugby. In Scotland, you may be injured away from a Champions Cup match – otherwise you are the captain of Team Bin Juice.

Too many gamers are now languishing on the periphery. George Horne could do with moving somewhere to become a first-choice melee half. Thomas Gordon It was great last season but fell into the long shadow cast by Rory Dargewhich itself was stuck in the Edinburgh back jamming before his turn west. On that side, Mike Blair must find a way to preserve Luke Crosbie, Jamie Ritchie, Hamish Watson, Nick Haining, Ben Muncaster, Connor BoyleKwagga van Niekerk, Bill Mata, Mesu Kunavula and, soon enough, Rudi Brownsatiated by playing time.

Glasgow leaves Grant Stewart and Hamish Bain go because they are stacked at a lovebird and lock. Edinburgh is gone Nathan Chamberlainpartly a victim of Blair Kinghorn’s sterling transition to a fly-half. Stafford McDowall, Charlie Shiel and Jack Blain has seen little action this term. All are good enough to be used on an URC level, but without a team to realize that potential.

1872 Edinburgh Cup
Pierre Schoeman and Hamish Watson is among the high-profile Scottish internationals to sign new deals (Photo by Robert Perry / Getty Images)

This is compounded by the tension of zones in England and of regulations in France. If you are a Stuart Hogg, Jonny Gray or Finno Russell, Your prospects are largely untouched. But if you belong to the increasingly limited middle class, which is neither English- nor French-qualified, and which constitutes the vast majority of the present market, you are also undertaking a search to find Lord Lucan as pursuing a decent contract. . The list of free agents this summer, most with a lot to offer, would bridge the Clyde. Some are forced to consider early retirement.

“Scottish players won’t want to hear this, but the appeal for them to Premiership clubs is declining,” says Jan McGinity, former head of sports operations at Scottish Rugby, who led a recruitment at Leicester and Worcester and worked as an eminent player agent.

“They must be released for international windows. There is always pressure for players, if they are not involved with the club, to go and train with Scotland even though they are not really intended. You know you will be without them for the Fall Tests, the Six Nations.

“Look at someone like that Dan Biggarwho is on £ 650,000 a year, he played about 10 games for Northampton last season – £ 65,000 pop is pretty expensive. “

This, combined with the declining salary cap in England and the declining interest in mid-level foreign players in France, inadvertently armed Scottish rugby with new financial power. They can afford to keep many of their main dogs at home, instead of being resigned to losing them due to much heavier pay packages.

Glasgow received two phenomena Leone Nakarawa and Niko Matawalu. Nakarawa was signed for misery and his final contract at Scotstoun was reportedly worth just £ 80,000 a year earlier. Race 92 added zero to it

Watson, Ritchie, Zander Fagerson, Darcy GrahamPierre Schoeman and Ali Price signed new agreements last year. Edinburgh can offer more money to Sam Skinner than Exeter Chiefs – risible notion a few seasons back – while Huw Jones returns to Glasgow, a move that will make Cole Forbeswho impressed early in his Warriors career, few favors. Josh McKaya serious operator, already in Glasgow and a New Zealander Wes Goosen will be an Edinburgh man next season, a pulse-speeding addition from the Hurricanes.

Scottish rugby has long lamented the influx of signatures from abroad, fearing the road for young Scots will be stifled. Here the recruiting superiors really earn their crust. Perhaps nowhere else in elite rugby are these decisions so essential. If a Scottish club signs from abroad, they must put a game changer online. Or they need someone who, through their personality, experience, and leadership, can have a transformative effect on those around them.

Glasgow received two phenomena in Leone Nakarawa and Niko Matawalu. Nakarawa was signed for misery and his final contract at Scotstoun was reportedly worth just £ 80,000 a year before Racing 92 added a zero to it. Mata was huge for Edinburgh and refused interest from France and Ulster because he was so well taken care of. You can run the range of Jack Dempsey and Emiliano Boffelli this season, a Josh Strauss and Netani TaleiDTH van der Merwe and WP Nelall the way back to Brendan Laney and Todd Blackadder.

It is no shock that many of the prominent imports were number eight, a position where Scotland has long struggled to produce its own, domestic colossus: Dempsey, Mata, Strauss, Talei, Cornell du Preez, Nasi Manu. Tonga giant Sione Vailanu is on its way to Glasgow from Worcester soon. South African and Pacific Island muscle completes the local harvest.

Leone Nakarawa
Leone Nakarawa was a huge hit in his first period with the Glasgow Warriors (Image – Photo Getty Images)

But for every Nakarawa, there is Langilangi Haupeakui. For each Boffelli, Sam Beard. For each Strauss, Tevita Tameilau. Get it right, and the pro-teams will be regulars in the URC finals and European knockouts. Wrong, and you end up with waste and blocking; it is difficult to know which is worse.

Under the elite game, the semi-professional Super6, now entering its second full season, is starting to serve its purpose. After being desperately beaten in the Under-20 Six Nations, Scottish coach Kenny Murray admitted that his players were physically unprepared to deal with the intensity of their rivals. The Super6 is the main tool to deal with this, but only recently have more of the U20s received a welcome exposure to men’s rugby. They can’t be so hopelessly failed again.

For the first time, Scotland has been able to meet the market value desire of players, so they don’t have to leave.

Finding slots for these players above on the ladder is however difficult. Take Robbie McCallum, for example, one of the outstanding players of the Super6, a 21-year-old academic center with a national age-grade experience and a lot to like about his game. There was nothing for him in Edinburgh and Glasgow, while Premiership clubs did not want to take a push based on semi-professional matches alone. McCallum goes to the English Championship where he will combine a part-time playing deal with office work in London.

“For the first time, Scotland has been able to meet the market value desired by players, so they don’t have to leave,” says McGinity. “Those shortcomings in the pro-teams won’t show up if fewer players move on.

“Where there is a backlog of talent in positions that Scotland has traditionally produced, that will be a further problem.

“Does that mean we have to look at – and I know this is an old argument in Scotland – a third pro-team?” I don’t think the finance is there. If not for covetousness, in another or two seasons this could be feasible. It may be ten years in line now. If you were to bring another franchise to the URC, I don’t know how big it can get, and I can’t see that another franchise is welcome right now because it would just dilute the problem. It’s far away.

Glasgow Sharks
Wallaby number eight Jack Dempsey was a great addition to the Glasgow squad (Photo by Ross MacDonald / SNS Group via Getty Images)

“They will have to find a way to allow one of these talents to get that discovery and that playing time and come back. Does that mean better relations with Premiership or Championship sides in England? There was a French relationship with Stade Nicois but you had to sign up for the season, you couldn’t be loaned back and forth.

“You have to think outside the box. Gregor Townsend will have that question: where do these guys get rugby? He will make sure that even if you have people coming to Scotland to qualify for housing, they are likely to block the way. “

Edinburgh, next season, will have a budget of around £ 8m. I think Glasgow will be closer to £ 7.6m- £ 7.8m. You actually have a significant number available to you, much higher than the English teams, which was never really the case.

But among the complexity lies an exciting nuisance. This season, Premiership clubs have been allowed to use “plus-one” contracts, activating additional years on existing deals that did not count towards the new £ 5m salary cap. Some, especially Bristol Bears, had their fingers burned while cutting costs and saving wages. Next term, those more units run out, players leave, and a truer picture of £ 5 million will emerge. Both Edinburgh and Glasgow will have larger warboxes than all their enemies south of the border and that is a very important issue.

“If you ranked where you could make the most money, you would go Japan first, France later, then on a few occasions URC teams, then the Prime Minister, “McGinity continues.

“Edinburgh will have a budget of around £ 8 million next season. I think Glasgow will be closer to £ 7.6m- £ 7.8m. You actually have a significant number available to you, much higher than the English teams, which that was never really the case. “

Opportunity strikes, if not, perhaps, for the young people coming through the system. So what does Scottish Rugby do about it? Where is the best place for your money? The top-down approach, investing heavily in the elite game in the hope of success inspiring a nation, has not borne fruit. A third pro-team would be a detrimental exercise on the heels of a pandemic, and where should one be based? Would the Premiership welcome Scottish fingerprints on one of their top 13 teams, and would there be any merit in Scottish Rugby investing in a Champions League that the RFU has significantly unfunded? That’s before we get to the women’s squad that needs and deserves full professional status with a World Cup threatening. For those above, there are no easy solutions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.